Sign in
More Frosting Please!
About
- 4.9 ( 15 reviews)
Located just to the west of Maggie's Closet, stop in and see our NEW location! 'More Frosting Please' is a Cakery in Plymouth, WI. Offering cakes for ALL occasions....wedding cakes to birthdays to showers to single cupcakes. We are fully licensed by the state of Wisconsin and have been decorating cakes for over 15 years! We have a store front location where our customers can come to pick up their special order cakes and we also sell our signature Premium Cupcakes, peanut squares, brownies and cookies too! At MFP we accept cake orders six days a week. We also offer superior wedding cakes for your Perfect Day. All you need to bring are your thoughts and ideas for your cake, and we will work together to come up with your dream come true. We can create unique cakes suited to your liking. Budget Friendly. Over 15 years of bakery/cake decorating experience. Fully licensed and insured!
| Day of the Week | Opening Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 9:00 - 17:00 |
| Tuesday | 9:00 - 17:00 |
| Wednesday | 9:00 - 16:00 |
| Thursday | 9:00 - 15:00 |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Cuisines
- 🍔 American
Dining Options
- 💺 Seating
- ♿ Wheelchair Accessible
- 🥡 Takeout
- 🅿️ Parking Available
- 💳 Accepts Credit Cards
- 🍳 Breakfast
Accepts Credit Cards
Recommended Reviews
4.9
Joy Bartlett
Love her cakes and cupcakes! So many flavors to choose from that are all delicious!
Jamie Eisentraut
I would say they were the best cupcakes and cake we have ever had. The cake was wonderfully decorated. We will definitely continue to do business with Shelly and recommend other people get there cupcakes and cakes from her.
Adrian Schneider
Great eats and treats. Shelly makes cakes/cupcakes for all occasions. Call to set up an appointment if you need a cake for a special occasion.
Questions & Answers
Nearest places
View all
Cheese Counter
- 4.8 (24)
- $$
- 118 ft from the location
The Bar-b-Que
- 4.5 (0)
- $$
- 249 ft from the location
52 Stafford Restaurant
- 4.5 (0)
- $$
- 397 ft from the location
Exchange Bank Coffee House
- 4.7 (43)
- $$
- 446 ft from the location
Antoinette's Casual Dining
- 4.6 (50)
- $$
- 646 ft from the location
PJ Campbells at the Depot
- 4.8 (50)
- $$
- 732 ft from the location
Hub City Restaurant
- 4.5 (0)
- $$
- 764 ft from the location
DeO's Pizzeria & Pub
- 4.5 (0)
- $$
- 823 ft from the location
Wild Shots Pub
- 4.6 (50)
- $$
- 935 ft from the location